Ask the Doctor: What tests determine whether a person has arthritis or osteoarthritis?
Monday, February 23rd, 2009Dr. John Pixley answers the question: “What tests determine whether a person has arthritis or osteoarthritis?”
Arthritis is a general term that identifies the area that is diseased or is painful. More often than not pains are not a reflection of arthritis at all and reflect muscle spasm, tendonitis, bursitis (a sac outside of a joint) or even disease in the abdomen or chest. A history, physical examination, laboratory and X-ray evaluation allow for establishing both the presence of arthritis and the proper diagnosis.
Once the clinical evaluation identifies that arthritis is present, the physician then determines whether it is part of a larger disease process or not.
Osteoarthritis is in essence a disease where the cartilage degenerates. Causes include genetics, obesity, deconditioning, previous injury and certain metabolic conditions, such as iron overload or thyroid disease. There is no specific test.
Treatment of osteoarthritis is directed at the underlying cause, as well as, minimizing further cartilage deterioration. Osteoarthritis of the knee is best studied and understood. Here, weight reduction, walking, medications to relieve pain, such as acetaminophen, and therapeutic exercises directed by a physical therapist have been shown to improve patient functioning.
The role of glucosamine is controversial. The best studied is DONA (glucosamine sulfate), which has received approval in Europe as a medication. Unfortunately, many of the preparations in commercial pharmacies, health food stores and Web sites have not been studied in a randomized controlled fashion to establish their effectiveness. Other therapies include joint injections with glucocorticoids and viscosupplements, which may provide benefit, and are approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Finally, total or partial joint replacement may be required if the cartilage deterioration is far advanced.
John Pixley, M.D. is an internist and rheumatologist in Reno, Nevada, with more than 30 years of medical experience. He practices with University Health System in Reno.
Have a question? University Health System doctors answer select questions from readers like you.

FUZE